分离的婴儿浴水

Mike Daisey国防的要点是,尽管他的作品故事不是真的,他们结合的故事画一个更大的真理错误戴西没有得到更大的事实相反,他画了一个大谎言。

昨天Daisey,在他的博客:

In the last forty-eight hours I have been equated with Stephen Glass, James Frey, and Greg Mortenson.

这是因为,像他们一样,戴西捏造出耸人听闻的故事并将其作为真理传递出去。

Given the tenor of the condemnation, you would think I had concocted an elaborate, fanciful universe filled with furnaces in which babies are burned to make iPhone components, or that I never went to China, never stood outside the gates of Foxconn, never pretended to be a businessman to get inside of factories, never spoke to any workers.

但毋庸置疑的是Daisey去中国没有人质疑他对富士康门外的工人说话。有争议的是什么是Daisey的故事的耸人听闻的方面:他遇到了几个未成年工人,他遇到了被毒害的工人n-hexane他遇到了一个男人,手上有永久受伤的人,他自己组装了iPad这个美国人的生活和罗伯·施密茨【Rob Schmitz】显示这些声称是捏造

Especially galling is how many are gleefully eager to dance on my grave expressly so they can return to ignoring everything about the circumstances under which their devices are made.

任何人都不会高兴串行制作者的郊游是悲伤没有人,由于Daisey被当成了骗子,现在想忽视中国工厂的劳动条件。

Given the tone, you would think I had fabulated an elaborate hoax, filled with astonishing horrors that no one had ever seen before.

“骗局”是正确的词,但语义道奇第二条款上面的句子的核心Daisey的防御工作:这并不重要,他实际上并没有看到他声称看到过的东西,因为所有的这些事情真的发生了,在某种程度上,在一些地方这非常具有误导性戴西的表演的全部观点,即他作为苹果劳工实践的主要批评者的地位,是他自己亲眼目睹了这些事情。

真实的事实 - 那未成年工人被发现那个结束了100名工人被暴露于正己烷伤害,结果是有一连串的自杀式跳跃富士康宿舍现在有可怕的安全网安装——已经被报道这些事实都是由其中包括的,Apple itself现在,你可以争辩说,苹果公司对这些事实的报道已经委婉地提出来,以公司的利益来展示这些事实。但不可否认的是,苹果自己也承认并报告所有我们知道真正的问题与公司的亚洲供应链。

我认为最强大的可信的概述在苹果的中国制造业的问题Charles Duhigg和David Barboza为纽约时报报道, 今年早些时候但重读之后他们的故事的时代,以及苹果自己的2012年,2011年和2010年供应商责任报告,我找不到任何由《纽约时报》报道,苹果公司本身并没有报道The Times’s report is more compelling; it adds color and punch and presents its conclusions more powerfully and emotionally through its use of a narrative但事实上,《纽约时报》的报道给人的范围和精度苹果自己的公开报道。

Daisey告诉一个完全不同的故事Daisey’s story was this: Not only did those things happen, but they are all ongoing problems, right now, today, and they are so rampant, so commonplace, that a big white American wearing a Hawaiian shirt — a man who’s never before been to China and speaks neither Mandarin nor Cantonese — can simply travel to Shenzhen, China and stand outside the Foxconn gates with a translator for a few shifts and he will find workers as young as 12, 13, and 14 walking out每一天,每一天在一次为期六天的旅行中,同一个男人可能会遇到一个在装配iPad时失去了一只手的男人一群工人正己烷中毒,34个小时轮班后一个人去死吧只是一个星期富士康。Mike Daisey的故事——相似性没有任何其他人报告了。

不仅仅是暗示而且明确地指出Daisey的“报道”的观点或多或少地表明,苹果公司只承认它所做的事情,并且事实远比公司自己的报告所承认的要糟糕。

Change.org上的热门在线请愿书已累积超过250,000个签名它始于:

You know what’s awesome? Listening to NPR podcasts through an Apple Airport, playing through a Mac laptop, while puttering about the kitchenDo you know the fastest way to replace awesome with a terrible knot in your stomach? Learning that your beloved Apple products are made in factories where conditions are so bad, it’s not uncommon for workers to permanently lose the use of their hands.

Last week’s This American Life shined a spotlight on the working conditions in the Chinese factories where iPhones are madeJust one example of the hardships there: the men and women in these factories work very long days spent repeating the same motions over and over, which creates amped-up carpal tunnel syndrome in their wrists and handsThis often results in them losing the use of their hands for the rest of their livesThis condition could be easily prevented if the workers were rotated through different positions in the factory, but they are notWhy? Because there are no labor laws in China to protect these people.

除了Mike Daisey之外,没有人报告过这种重复性压力损伤他做了250000人相信他——即使是小角色,因为爱尔兰共和军玻璃和美国生活的可信度,签署了一份请愿书这里没有更大的真理这不是一个错误这只是一个谎言,一个谎言被告知要引起注意并以牺牲实际真相为代价来创造同情。


最令人震惊的Daisey谎言来自“史蒂夫乔布斯的痛苦和狂喜”中的以下内容你可以在第31页阅读可下载的成绩单你可以看Daisey执行这个段通过观看这份报告来自哥伦比亚广播公司的新闻,1月播出,从2点左右开始我建议观看,因为Daisey确实是一位才华横溢的演员。

But I do know that in my first two hours of my first day at that gate, I met workers who were fourteen years old, I met workers who were thirteen years old, I met workers who were twelve.

你真的认为苹果不知道吗?

In a company obsessed with the details, with the aluminum being milled just so, with the glass being fitted perfectly into the case, do you really think it’s credible that they don’t know?

这不是关于“更大的真理”,有违反童工在苹果供应商这是一个很大的谎言:作为一个机构的苹果公司及其高管个人对儿童的福利漠不关心,无论是对我们说谎还是向另一方面说话。

真相,只要别人报道——苹果本身,《纽约时报》引述是未成年工人在苹果供应商是非常罕见的苹果2011年供应商责任报告引用91个实例(总共约500,000名工人)他们的2012年报告指出:

We discovered a total of 6 active and 13 historical cases of underage labor at 5 facilitiesIn each case, the facility had insufficient controls to verify age or detect false documentation. We found no instances of intentional hiring of underage labor.

We required the suppliers to support the young workers’ return to school and to improve their management systems — such as labor recruitment practices and age verification procedures — to prevent recurrences.

实际更大的真理——未成年工人,不安全条件,艰苦的时间,拥挤的宿舍,都是真实的问题,值得我们关注。但这正是苹果本身已经说了五年了。这也是“纽约时报”和ABC夜线的记者多年来的报道。

戴西谴责苹果公司的诚信 - 以及新闻业ABC新闻——为了工作人就不存在的问题这只会引起人们对苹果亚洲供应链中劳动力,健康和环境问题的关注存在。

他损害了真正的原因,而不是帮助。

戴西,接近尾声他的“我不会离开”昨天:

我相信事实是极其重要的I continue to believe that我相信我会回答我所做的事情。

如果实际上Daisey相信任何,他从来没有执行他的节目我认为Daisey真的相信他值得关注他的谎言带来了他,所以他不打算告诉他们停止。